Who Are the Four Horsemen of Atheism?

The Four Horsemen of atheism are Richard Dawkins, Christopher Hitchens, Sam Harris and Daniel C. Dennett. Christopher Hitchens dubbed the quartet the Four Horsemen of the Counter-Apocalypse. Each published a best-known book on religion between 2004 and 2007, and all four sat together in Washington, D.C., in 2007 for a filmed conversation that Random House published in print in 2019.

NameDisciplineKey workDied
Richard DawkinsEvolutionary biologyThe God Delusion (2006)Living
Christopher HitchensJournalism and criticismGod Is Not Great (2007)15 December 2011
Sam HarrisNeuroscience and philosophyThe End of Faith (2004)Living
Daniel C. DennettPhilosophy of mindBreaking the Spell (2006)19 April 2024

Who Named Them and What the Label Means

The name comes from Christopher Hitchens, who referred to the group as the Four Horsemen of the Counter-Apocalypse. The original Four Horsemen are figures drawn from the Book of Revelation in the Christian Bible, traditionally associated with conquest, war, famine and death. Hitchens inverted the imagery deliberately: where the biblical horsemen signal an apocalypse, this quartet presented themselves as a counter-force to what they regarded as the destructive influence of organised religion on public life.

The label arrived alongside a wider press designation. In November 2006, Wired published Gary Wolf’s article The Church of the Non-Believers, which described Dawkins, Harris and Dennett as the New Atheists and identified Dawkins as the leading light of the New Atheism movement. The term New Atheism was quickly adopted by journalists and commentators to distinguish this openly confrontational, media-savvy approach from earlier forms of secular or humanist thought that had tended to treat religion as a private matter beyond public challenge. Whether the approach was genuinely new, or simply louder, became one of the recurring debates among both critics and supporters of the movement.

Understanding where atheism sits in relation to other non-religious positions is a background question for many readers. The article on agnostic vs atheist sets out those distinctions in detail.

The Four Individuals: Backgrounds and Books

Each of the four brought a different professional background to the project of public atheism, and that variety was part of what gave the group its breadth of appeal across different readerships.

Richard Dawkins

Richard Dawkins was born on 26 March 1941 in Nairobi, Kenya, and trained as an evolutionary biologist. He first gained wide recognition with The Selfish Gene in 1976, a popular science book that reframed evolutionary theory around the gene rather than the organism or the species. The book introduced the concept of the meme, a cultural unit of transmission analogous to a gene, which later entered everyday language.

Nothing in Dawkins’s earlier career drew a response to match The God Delusion, published in 2006. The book argues that belief in a personal god is not merely mistaken but constitutes a delusion in a meaningful sense, that the existence of God is a scientific hypothesis subject to examination, and that children raised within a specific religion without opportunity to question it are being subjected to a form of harm. The God Delusion became a bestseller in multiple countries and prompted extensive theological and philosophical response. Dawkins also launched the Out Campaign in 2007, encouraging non-believers to identify themselves openly rather than keeping their atheism private.

Dawkins’s argument that science and religious belief are fundamentally in tension is examined further in the article on science without religion.

Christopher Hitchens

Christopher Hitchens was born on 13 April 1949 in Portsmouth, England, and became a British American author, essayist and literary critic with a reputation for polemical argument across a wide range of subjects. He wrote for publications on both the political left and right over the course of his career and was known for taking positions that crossed conventional ideological lines.

His contribution to the Four Horsemen moment was God Is Not Great: How Religion Poisons Everything, published in 2007. The book argues that religion is not merely false but actively harmful, tracing what Hitchens presented as a pattern of violence, suppression and intellectual dishonesty across the major world faiths. God Is Not Great became a bestseller and was widely described as a rallying cry and manifesto for the atheist movement. Hitchens died on 15 December 2011 in Houston, Texas, following a diagnosis of oesophageal cancer that he had written about with characteristic directness.

Sam Harris

Sam Harris brought a background in neuroscience and philosophy to his public arguments about religion. His book The End of Faith was published in August 2004 and won the 2005 PEN Award for Nonfiction. The book’s central argument is that religious faith, treated as a category exempt from rational scrutiny, poses a specific danger in an era of modern weaponry, because it can motivate extreme action on the basis of beliefs that cannot be questioned from within the belief system itself.

Harris followed that book with Letter to a Christian Nation, published in September 2006. The shorter work was written in direct response to the thousands of letters he received from Christians after The End of Faith appeared, and it addresses arguments those correspondents had raised. His focus on the relationship between belief and behaviour gave the group’s overall argument a strand of practical ethics alongside Dawkins’s biological perspective and Hitchens’s literary polemicism.

Daniel C. Dennett

Daniel C. Dennett was born on 28 March 1942 in Boston and was an American philosopher of mind who became a prominent figure in the atheist movement at the beginning of the 21st century. He had been a significant voice in debates about consciousness, free will and the nature of mind long before the New Atheism moment arrived. His books Consciousness Explained (1991) and Darwin’s Dangerous Idea (1995) were widely read outside academic philosophy and established him as one of the leading scientific naturalists of his generation.

His direct contribution to the religious debate was Breaking the Spell: Religion as a Natural Phenomenon, published in 2006. The book’s argument is that religion itself can and should be studied as a natural phenomenon, subject to scientific and philosophical investigation rather than placed beyond it. Dennett was perhaps the most academically measured of the four, and his presence gave the group credibility in philosophical circles. He died on 19 April 2024 in Portland, Maine, having remained intellectually active into his eighties.

The 2007 Conversation and the 2019 Book

In 2007, Hitchens, Dawkins, Harris and Dennett sat down together over cocktails and filmed a discussion about modern atheism. According to a review from The Bookseller quoted on the publisher’s page, the conversation took place in Washington, D.C. The filmed discussion circulated online and introduced many viewers to the four as a group rather than as individual writers.

The transcript was published in print for the first time on 19 March 2019 by Random House, under the title The Four Horsemen: The Conversation That Sparked an Atheist Revolution. The book also contains new essays reflecting on the conversation and its context, written to accompany the original transcript. The subtitle’s claim that the conversation sparked a revolution is itself a matter of debate, but the publication confirmed the group’s status as a recognised historical phenomenon rather than simply a journalistic label.

The conversation covered the nature of religious belief, the relationship between science and faith, the question of whether religion deserves a form of special respect in public discourse, and the ethics of criticising beliefs that many people hold with great personal sincerity. The four participants did not always agree on emphasis or approach, and those internal differences are visible in the transcript. Dennett leaned towards the analytical and academic; Hitchens towards the literary and historical; Dawkins towards the scientific; and Harris towards the ethical and psychological.

How the Label New Atheism Was Used

The term New Atheism, used in Gary Wolf’s November 2006 article in Wired, captured something real about the moment. Earlier generations of secular thinkers had often argued for a live-and-let-live approach to religious belief, treating faith as a private matter that did not require public challenge. The Four Horsemen, by contrast, argued that religious belief has public consequences and that treating it as immune from criticism is itself a form of intellectual and social error.

This posture was described by its proponents as honesty and by its critics as aggression. The movement’s core claim is that the same standards of evidence and argument that apply to any other factual claim should apply to claims about the existence of God, the authority of scripture and the moral teachings derived from them. That question connects directly to the broader debate examined in the article on is God real.

The label New Atheism was adopted widely enough that it became a common term in journalism for the phenomenon associated with these four writers and their contemporaries. Critics of the label pointed out that atheism itself is ancient and that there was nothing philosophically novel in the positions the four were advancing. Defenders of the term responded that what was new was not the conclusion but the public manner of arguing for it: through bestselling popular books, lecture tours, television appearances and, increasingly, online video.

Theological and Critical Responses

The Four Horsemen attracted substantial critical response from theologians, philosophers of religion and literary intellectuals, and not all of it came from people who were themselves religious believers.

One of the most discussed responses came from the literary critic Terry Eagleton. Writing in the London Review of Books on 19 October 2006, Eagleton’s review of The God Delusion, titled Lunging, Flailing, Mispunching, argued that critics of religion who ignore theology come up with vulgar caricatures of religious faith. Eagleton’s central charge was that Dawkins, and by extension the broader movement, was engaging with a simple, literalist version of religious belief rather than with the sophisticated theological traditions that have developed over centuries. In Eagleton’s view, attacking the God of popular belief without engaging with the God of serious theology is comparable to attacking science by reference only to its worst popular misrepresentations.

This critique was echoed in various forms by theologians and philosophers of religion across different traditions. The charge was not that the Four Horsemen were wrong to criticise religion, but that they were doing so without adequate knowledge of what they were criticising. Some argued that the movement’s confidence was itself a kind of dogmatism, mirroring the certainty it claimed to oppose.

Supporters of the Four Horsemen responded that the sophisticated theological traditions Eagleton had in mind were largely unknown to the majority of religious believers, and that it is the popular, practised form of religion that has actual consequences in the world rather than the refined positions of academic theologians. This dispute about which version of religion is the appropriate target of criticism remained one of the central unresolved arguments in the New Atheism debate.

Other critics raised concerns about tone. The polemical confidence of God Is Not Great and The God Delusion in particular was seen by some readers, including some atheists and agnostics, as counterproductive: more likely to entrench the positions of religious believers than to persuade them. Some critics from within secular traditions argued that the movement’s confrontational approach made productive dialogue with moderate religious communities more difficult.

There were also substantive philosophical objections. Critics argued that the Four Horsemen’s arguments were primarily effective against naive theological positions and had less purchase on the more carefully argued versions of theism developed in academic philosophy of religion. The debate about the existence and nature of God has a long and technically demanding history, and critics suggested that the popular books of the New Atheism movement engaged with that history only selectively.

The Non-Religious in Numbers

Whatever assessment one makes of the Four Horsemen’s arguments, the broader trend towards religious disaffiliation that was visible during their most prominent years has continued. The religiously unaffiliated numbered 1.9 billion in 2020, a figure that includes atheists, agnostics and people who describe their religion as nothing in particular. This group represents a substantial portion of the global population and is not confined to Western liberal democracies, though the distribution is uneven across regions.

The Four Horsemen did not cause this trend, which has roots in longer processes of secularisation, education and urbanisation. However, their books and public appearances contributed to a cultural environment in which non-belief became more openly speakable, and in which the absence of religion was treated by a larger public audience as a position that could be argued for rather than simply lived quietly. Dawkins’s Out Campaign of 2007, which encouraged non-believers to identify themselves publicly, was a direct attempt to make visible a population that was often statistically undercounted because many non-believers did not advertise their position.

Frequently Asked Questions

Who gave the Four Horsemen their name?

Christopher Hitchens named the group the Four Horsemen of the Counter-Apocalypse, borrowing the imagery from the Book of Revelation and inverting it to describe a force opposing religious influence rather than heralding a biblical end of days.

What was the first book to emerge from the Four Horsemen group?

Sam Harris’s The End of Faith, published in August 2004, was the earliest of the major books associated with the group. It won the 2005 PEN Award for Nonfiction and preceded the other key texts by two years.

What was the significance of the 2007 filmed conversation?

The filmed conversation, recorded in Washington, D.C., brought all four together on screen and circulated online. It was eventually published in print by Random House on 19 March 2019 as The Four Horsemen: The Conversation That Sparked an Atheist Revolution, accompanied by new essays.

What is the main theological criticism of the Four Horsemen?

The most prominent version of this criticism was made by Terry Eagleton in the London Review of Books in October 2006. Eagleton argued that critics of religion who ignore theology produce only vulgar caricatures of religious faith, engaging with popular belief rather than with serious theological traditions.

Is New Atheism a formally organised movement?

No. The term New Atheism was a label applied by journalists, among them Gary Wolf in Wired in November 2006, to describe a loose tendency among a group of writers and public intellectuals. There is no organisation, membership or agreed programme associated with it.

How many people worldwide have no religious affiliation?

The religiously unaffiliated numbered 1.9 billion in 2020, encompassing atheists, agnostics and those who describe their religion as nothing in particular. This figure covers a wide range of positions and levels of conviction rather than a single coherent group.

Summary

The Four Horsemen of atheism are Richard Dawkins, Christopher Hitchens, Sam Harris and Daniel C. Dennett, a name Christopher Hitchens gave the group himself. Each brought a distinct discipline to public debates about religion: Dawkins an evolutionary biologist, Hitchens a literary journalist and critic, Harris a philosopher and neuroscientist, and Dennett a philosopher of mind. Their key books, The End of Faith (2004), The God Delusion (2006), Breaking the Spell (2006) and God Is Not Great (2007), appeared within a three-year window.

The term New Atheism was applied to them by the press, most prominently in Gary Wolf’s November 2006 article in Wired. Their 2007 filmed conversation in Washington, D.C., circulated widely and was published in full by Random House in 2019. The main critical response from theologians and intellectuals, exemplified by Terry Eagleton’s review in the London Review of Books, accused the group of engaging with caricatures of religion rather than with serious theology. By 2020, the religiously unaffiliated worldwide numbered 1.9 billion, a figure that reflects trends far larger than any single intellectual movement but within which the Four Horsemen occupied a visible and contested place.

Sources

  • Encyclopaedia Britannica, "Christopher Hitchens". britannica.com.
  • Encyclopaedia Britannica, "Richard Dawkins". britannica.com.
  • Encyclopaedia Britannica, "new atheism". britannica.com.
  • Encyclopaedia Britannica, "Daniel C. Dennett". britannica.com.
  • Sam Harris, "The End of Faith" (book page). samharris.org.
  • Sam Harris, "Letter to a Christian Nation" (book page). samharris.org.
  • Penguin Random House, "The Four Horsemen" by Christopher Hitchens, Richard Dawkins, Sam Harris and Daniel Dennett. penguinrandomhouse.com.
  • Gary Wolf, "The Church of the Non-Believers", Wired (1 November 2006). wired.com.
  • Terry Eagleton, "Lunging, Flailing, Mispunching", London Review of Books, Vol. 28 No. 20 (19 October 2006). lrb.co.uk.
  • Pew Research Center, "How the Global Religious Landscape Changed From 2010 to 2020" (9 June 2025). pewresearch.org.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top